Lessons from the Portal Bridge Cutover Schedule

–

–

Service Improvements Available

At this writing, NJ Transit is running trains on a special schedule to accommodate the cutover from the old Portal Bridge over the Hackensack River to the new Portal North Bridge. The 5-week project is similar to that of last February and March. The biggest change is that weekday service on the Morris & Essex (M&E) and Montclair lines, along with 2 round-trip commuter runs on the Gladstone Branch, have been rerouted to Hoboken. Weekend service is also different.  Because of the temporary schedule, the agency altered the schedules in ways that could improve mobility if they are made permanent. This article will focus on the Lackawanna Coalition’s primary lines of concern: the M&E, Montclair–Boonton, and Gladstone lines.

For 15 weeks at the height of the covid-19 pandemic in 2020, NJ Transit reduced service, primarily at peak-commuting periods. The standard “off-peak” pattern of hourly service was maintained in most places, and there was a “mini-peak” on the M&E, which resulted from a request that I had made on behalf of the Coalition.  In some instances, schedules were improved over the “regular” operating pattern. Gladstone Branch service was the best in the line’s history. The weekend schedule, without the annoying gap of more than 4 hours between trains in the “reverse” direction (outbound in the morning and inbound in late afternoon and early evening) still ran, as did the 2 “commuter trains” to or from New York Penn Station in the prevailing direction. Trains ran later on weeknights, too. The last train of the night on the M&E left New York every night at 1:19 a.m.; 23 minutes later than the customary 12:56 weeknight (including Friday nights) departure. The final outbound weekday trains ran later elsewhere on the system, too. M&E trains also stopped at Secaucus during peak-commuting periods, which facilitated connections with Main–Bergen, Pascack Valley, and Port Jervis trains. All these improvements, including filling the long, annoying gap in Gladstone service, were withdrawn when “normal” schedules returned.

Once again, NJ Transit has an opportunity to keep some schedule improvements after “normal” operation is restored.  Riders will be glad to see weekday trains on the M&E and other lines of Lackawanna Railroad heritage return to Penn Station, and it should not be difficult to keep the improvements that came with the temporary schedule.

Riders accustomed to going directly to or from Penn Station will be glad to have Midtown Direct service return, and some Hoboken service will remain. There are some changes on weekends that have resulted in increased mobility for riders on these lines, and there is reason to encourage NJ Transit to keep those changes, at least if Amtrak will go along.

Trains run hourly as under the “regular” schedule, but essentially 20 minutes earlier than usual, leaving Dover at or about 40 minutes after the hour, rather than at :03 or :05, and leaving New York at 51 minutes after the hour instead of at the customary :11.  Gladstone trains are shuttles that connect with the M&E at Summit; Montclair trains go to Hoboken and also connect with Penn Station trains at Broad Street Station in Newark.  Normally, M&E passengers do not have enough time to travel between Broad Street Station and Penn Station in Newark for trips between the Coalition’s lines of primary concern and Trenton or Raritan trains on the Newark Division.  There are no connections at all to or from the North Jersey Coast Line, so most passengers must add 60 minutes of travel time in each directions.

The temporary schedule allows comfortable connections (30 to 40 minutes) to get from Broad Street to Penn Station.  The other direction is not as good, with 45 to 60 minutes allowed, but connections to and from the Shore are now available, with the risk of an additional 60 minutes of travel time essentially eliminated.

The span of weekend service is now longer than under the customary schedule, too. The first train from Penn Station now leaves at 6:51 a.m. instead of 7:11, and from Dover at 4:39 instead of 5:03.  The last train leaves from Penn Station at 1:41 a.m. instead of 1:19, and that from Dover now leaves at 11:39 p.m. instead of 11:03.  That’s almost an hour added to the span of service in both directions.  There is reason to assert that the “temporary” weekend schedule should become permanent (at least restored at the next planned change), with one minor exception.  All trains leave Penn Station at :51 after the hours, except the final one of the night, which leaves at 1:41, ten minutes earlier.  It is an unwise policy to send the final train of the night out in advance of the customary time on a “memory schedule” because riders who rely on the “normal” departure time stand an increased chance of being stranded for the night.  It would be easy to change that time to 1:51.

There are improvements on the Montclair branch, too.  Trains now leave Hoboken 5 minutes after their connecting trains leave Penn Station, comporting with the shorter travel time to Broad Street Station in Newark.  Under the “regular” schedule, they leave 1 or 3 minutes ahead of the New York departures and wait longer at Newark.

There is also a longer service day.  The first train leaves Bay Street Station at 6:31 a.m. instead of 7:00 on the “regular” schedule, and the last train leaves at 12:31 a.m. instead of midnight, making the span of service 18 hours, not 17.  The first connecting train leaves Penn Station at 6:51 and the last at 12:51, although hourly service would add an extra hour to the usable service day.  Another benefit is that trains run every 2 hours, because the 3-hour gap in the evening (between 9:00 and 12:00 midnight on inbound trains and between 8:11 and 11:11 p.m. on outbound connecting trains) has been eliminated in the temporary schedule.  Making that change permanent will improve mobility for Montclair line riders by avoiding unduly long gaps.

However, weekend trains running 2 hours apart is still not at acceptable.  The Lackawanna Coalition, ROUTE (Restore OUr Transit in Essex), and the New Jersey Association of Railroad Passengers (NJ-ARP) are all advocating for hourly weekend service between Hoboken and Montclair State University Station (and further west, if feasible) on a schedule connecting at Newark with M&E trains in both directions.  The current schedule improves the feasibility of this proposed service enhancement. Outbound trains are scheduled to arrive at Bay Street in Montclair at 28 minutes past the odd hour.  They leave for Hoboken again at 31 minutes past the even hour; a 63-minute scheduled layover. On weekdays, most trains are scheduled to take 16 to 18 minutes to travel between Bay Street Station and Montclair State University Station (a few are scheduled to take a few minutes longer). Thus, there should be sufficient time allotted for the same weekend trains to run to Montclair State University (where the electrification ends) and turn around.  Allowing 18 minutes of travel time each way, with 10 minutes for the brake test and other activities required during the layover, adds up to 46 minutes.  So trains can be extended to Montclair State if the current schedule is made permanent, and no additional crews or train sets will be needed for that extension, except for the additional crew and train set required to increase service from every 2 hours to every hour.

So it would make sense for NJ Transit to retain some of these service improvements from the temporary Cutover Schedule at first opportunity after “normal” schedules go back into effect.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *